Here in Milano, on Columbus Day 2018

Here in Milano, where my daughters attend an American school, which observes American holidays, they will have October 8^thoff as their school celebrates Columbus Day.

Christopher Columbus was an Italian navigator and colonist who sailed for Spain, who we were told in elementary school, discovered America.

And by America, we mean he discovered the Bahamas, South America, Central America, and Cuba. The only parts of the United States we can truthfully say Columbus discovered are the Virgin Islands and Puerto Rico.

And when we say discovered, we need to mention that Columbus was absolutely convinced he had made it to the Indies, calling the inhabitants “Indians,” a mistake which requires continuous clarification to this day. There is, in fact, no consensus amongst historians that he ever understood that he had landed on a continent that was previously unknown—unknown, that is, to Europeans.

Video: Here in Milano, on Columbus Day

Because when we say discovered, we must exclude the voyages of Lief Erikson, the Norse explorer who set foot on the Americas about 500 years before Columbus landed on San Salvador.

And when we say discovered, we must definitely exclude the inhabitants of the islands whose ancestors had lived in the Americas for well over 13,000 years.

The Arawaks were curious about the Columbus and his men, and as it has been noted in multiple reports, they very open and very generous. In his captain’s log, Columbus wrote, “They would make fine servants. With fifty men we could subjugate them all and make them do whatever one wished.”

And so Columbus subjugated them. His men took women and children as slaves for sex and labor. He forced the men into the mines to dig for gold. If they did not reach their quotas, his men would hack off their hands. When the terrified Arawaks tried to escape into the hills, the Spaniards sent their dogs to hunt them down and kill them.

Historian Howard Zinn writes, “Trying to put together an army of resistance, the Arawaks faced Spaniards who had armor, muskets, swords and horses. When the Spaniards took prisoners they hanged them or burned them to death. Among the Arawaks, mass suicides began. Infants were killed to save them from the Spaniards.

“In two years, through murder, mutilation, or suicide, half of the 250,000 Indians on Haiti were dead. . . . By the year 1515, there were perhaps fifty thousand Indians left. By 1550, there were 500. A report of the year 1650 shows none of the original Arawaks or their descendants left on the island.”

As a kid, the explorations had been my favorite part of American history. I loved the maps of the voyages. I loved the early maps that showed the Americas as barely recognizable landmasses, that grew more realistic as more explorations were made, as more information was gathered.

While Columbus’s first voyage across the Atlantic may have been the 1492 equivalent of Apollo 11, I now think the whole thing makes for a wildly inappropriate national holiday for the United States.

And by inappropriate, I mean for the enlightenment-inspired “all men are created equal” United States; the United States that was founded on freedom of speech, freedom of the press, equality, and religious tolerance; the United States that fought against the Nazis in World War Two, the United States that welcomed immigrants with open arms, especially, especially those fleeing existential life-threatening situations; the United States that was founded on the belief the government’s primary purpose is to protect the rights of its people, that all people are entitled to certain rights by virtue of simply being human. For that America, celebrating Columbus Day is totally inappropriate.

As opposed to the other America, the one that decimated the Native American population, put citizens of Japanese ancestry into concentration camps, that not only stands by but stands in the way as women are shamed after coming forward after being raped or sexually harassed; the America that sits by today while law-abiding African American citizens are murdered by police officers who are not held accountable, who are not even safe in their own homes.

The America that does not welcome immigrants seeking asylum, but actively destroys families by taking their children.

Now for that America, celebrating Columbus—who not only initiated the trans-Atlantic slave trade, but also engineered the first genocide of indigenous people in the New World—for that America, celebrating the mercenary sailor Christopher Columbus is totally appropriate.

———————————————————————————

An earlier version of this column appeared here a year ago